Piltdown Hoax

Piltdown hoax


The story of the Piltdown man begins in East Sussex. An amateur Archeologist (Charles Dawson) at the gravel pit near the village of Piltdown discovered a skull. By 1912 popular press spread the news. Many scientists were skeptical of the findings; however, they didn’t want to challenge Charles Dawson and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. In 1953 Kenneth P. Oakley, who was a professor of Anthropology at Oxford University applied modern technology and found out that the Piltdown skulls were hoaxes. It was a combination of fragments of a medieval man’s skull, an orangutan’s jawbone and chimpanzee’s teeth. The skull was chemically treated to look older. Oakley and his researchers found out that the jaw was of a 500 year old Orangutan which was chemically aged. Microscopic studies showed that the teeth came from fossilized chimpanzee which were modified to look more human.
Prior to this finding, the hoax created distorted family tree for modern man and his ancestors.
We don’t know the person behind this act, however, Charles Dawson seems to be the prime suspect. There isn’t enough evidence that he was the perpetrator of the hoax and he died in 1916 without any confessions. Other suspects include Pierre Teillhard de Chardin (who was hired to do the digging) and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (who was an Anatomist and the Piltdown man provided him with enough evidence for his theory on Human evolution). Martin Hinten is another suspect who was a workman at the natural museum (and became a Zoologist later).


The human fault that influenced this finding was the desire to find the earliest Englishman. This is a clear example for letting the personal interests influence the results. The hoax started because of national pride, jealousy and went on for such a long time because some people preferred to believe in it and ignore the reality.  


The positive aspect of scientific process that was responsible for revealing the skull to be fraud was Fluorine Test. By measuring the fluorine content of the fossil scientist could roughly date them. In 1949 scientists conducted a Fluorine test and found out that the remains were very young (about Hundred Thousand years old).



I don’t think removing “human factor” from science is necessary because humans are able to get educated and propose new theories. Although some theories might be rejected, the beauty of science is in its infinite opportunity to find another theory with better evidence to support a hypothesis (or reject it and look for another hypothesis).



This historical event reminded me of the importance of replication in science. In other words, science enables researchers to follow and repeat the measurements (findings) and in this case by following the measurements another scientist found the truth. I also learned not to take information in face value without any verification. This historical event is another reason why we should be critical thinkers and don’t believe in everything that we are being told.






Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Pertussis (Whooping Cough)

Image
Definition Pertussis (Whooping Cough) is an acute disease of the respiratory tract. Found in children younger than 5 years, especially in children age 2-3 years. Cause Pertussis is caused by gram-negative Bordetella Pertussis. Clinical Overview These symptoms occur 1-2 weeks after contact with the infected person and preceded by an incubation period of 7-14 days. Typically, the disease lasts for 6 weeks or more. That is why the disease is called cough hundred days. On his way, pertussis includes several stages, namely: Kataralis which marked the onset of a mild cough, especially at night, accompanied by mild fever and runny nose. This stage lasts 1-2 weeks. In the catarrhal stage indistinguishable from that caused by a viral respiratory infection Second is the spasmodic stage lasts 2-4 weeks. Symptoms, cough more often, people with sweat, and blood vessels in the face of wide-neck. Long coughing attack usually ends with a distinctive high-pitched sound (whooping caugh) and accompanied ...
Read more

Hemothorax

Image
Hemotorax is the presence of blood in the pleural cavity. Pathophysiology and Etiology Sharp trauma or blunt trauma. This can occur when blunt trauma can cause fractures of the ribs, resulting in a torn intercostal blood vessels and also cause a tear in the lung tissue. A torn aortic aneurysm Complications due to drug administration on pulmonary infarction antikoagulansia In patients with abnormalities of "hemorrhagic diathese". Complications in thoracic surgery. Clinical Symptoms Symptoms and complaints hemothorax depending on the weight and severity of trauma. Patients may complain of shortness of breath, chest pain, until the shock and anemia. Diagnosis 1. Anamnesa : A history of trauma to the chest, or after surgery. 2. Physical examination Found such signs in the pleural effusion . At the hospital hemitoraks reduced movement. Hemithorax percussion on the sick and faint sounds on auscultation, breath sounds audible reduced or disappear altogether. 3. Chest X-ray photo...
Read more

Cough - Definition and Mechanisms

Image
Cough Cough is a symptom of the most common disease in which the prevalence was found in about 15% in children and 20% in adults. One out of ten patients who visited the doctor's office each year has a chief complaint of cough. Coughing can cause bad feelings, sleep disorders, affecting daily activities and reduce quality of life. Cough is a complex physiological reflex that protects the lung from mechanical trauma, chemical and temperature. Coughing is also a natural defense mechanism of lung airway to keep it clean and open to the street: Prevent the entry of foreign objects into the respiratory tract. Remove foreign objects or abnormal secretions from the respiratory tract. Coughing becomes physiologically when perceived as a nuisance. Such a cough is often a sign of a disease within or outside the lungs and sometimes are the early symptoms of a disease. Cough may be very significant on the transmission of disease through the air (air-borne infection). Cough is one of the sympto...
Read more